All-But-Dissertation Candidates
Find Help
at Camp Run by UCD's Foss
By Marianne Goodland
Silver & Gold Record
During the summer, college campuses often
become places for band or cheerleading camps and visits from
prospective students. But last month, a dozen scholars were cloistered
in a dormitory at the University of Denver, participating in
a camp that will move many from graduate student to tenure-track
faculty.
While it's formally known as the "Scholar's Retreat,"
it's better known to graduate students and others who just can't
quite finish their dissertations as the ABD (All But Dissertation)
Boot Camp.
The camp is for students who have completed the coursework for
a
doctoral degree but have had trouble finishing their dissertations.
Under the direction of Sonja Foss of communication at CU-Denver,
students who attend the retreat break through the emotional barriers,
writer's blocks or other impediments that keep them from completing
a crucial step in their doctoral programs. The camp boasts a
remarkable success rate after its fourth year: all 36 students
who had attended before this June completed their dissertations,
and only one person chose not to defend hers later.
Foss operates the program independently of CU-Denver and charges
a fee for the service. Students are housed this year at a dorm
at the University of Denver, and can stay for one or two weeks.
The cost is $1,400 for two weeks or $950 for one week, and many
universities pay
for their working ABDs. Scholarships also are available.
Foss got the idea for the camp after a former student at the
University of Oregon asked Foss for help with her dissertation.
The student came to Denver, stayed for a week, and left with
a completed first draft. Foss said she figured out a technique
for helping the student, and has applied it in succeeding years.
She said many ABDs who have trouble finishing their dissertations
often have the physical work done, such as organizing books and
coding data, but lack a conceptual roadmap for proceeding. Foss
helps them come up with that roadmap and a plan for completing
chapters. "We make it manageable and concrete," she
said. She is a proponent of "fast-writing," which compels
the students to write down their ideas without worrying about
whether every word or sentence is perfect. Sometimes she even
hangs something over the computer screen so the
student can't see what he or she is writing.
"Most students are used to writing only when the inspiration
hits," Foss said. But at the camp, students are on rigorous
schedules where they are expected to write from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m.,
breaking only for meals. In this way, Foss said, they learn to
be productive without waiting for inspiration.
Many of the students at the camp had stuffed their dissertations
into boxes, some for years. Julie Friedline is a working ABD
in communication at the University of St. Thomas in St. Paul,
Minn. She attained ABD status in 1996 at the University of Iowa,
but now finds herself at a deadline--without the dissertation,
she won't be considered for a tenure-track job. She attended
the boot camp for two weeks, arriving with an outline of her
dissertation and all the materials she needed. She left with
a completed rough draft. "I never expected that," she
said. "I'm very pleased." Friedline said Foss is a
tough taskmaster, but one who has created a completely supportive
academic environment where students can focus strictly on writing.
Foss first advertised the program in communication journals,
but not all the students who come to boot camp are in the communication
field. This year, the first students in geography and English
attended the camp. Andrea Penner, a graduate student at the University
of New Mexico, worked on her dissertation in Native American
literature. She brought a prospectus to camp but hadn't started
writing. She left with her second chapter close to completion
and a schedule for defending her dissertation in six months.
"I floundered around for a year and a half," Penner
said, adding that she lacked confidence that her ideas had merit.
Foss and assistant director William Waters, a graduate of the
camp now at the University of New Mexico, helped Penner get from
reading and analyzing to saying something meaningful and assisted
her in presenting her ideas and in finding ways to highlight
her points rather than highlighting the text she had analyzed.
Another "camper," Hilary Anne Frost-Kumpf is director
of the community arts management program at the University of
Illinois-Springfield. She is in the second year of a tenure-track
position but must complete her dissertation in geography to keep
that appointment. Frost-Kumpt said she had pieces of the paper
finished but no good roadmap of where to go from there. She left
the camp with two-and-a-half chapters done and a clear plan for
finishing the entire document. While Foss comes from a different
discipline, Frost-Kumpf pointed out that the value of the camp
was "the expertise in the structure of the dissertation,
how to put it together, plus the discipline of the schedule and
the community that arises in camp." Foss added that the
camp applies best to students who are in qualitative fields in
arts and humanities or social sciences because of the methodology
she employs at the camp.
Foss reported that she turned away students for this year's camp,
something she hasn't done before. However, she isn't alone in
her efforts to help students with their dissertations. The CU-Boulder
Center for Humanities and the Arts offers a dissertation fellowship
to assist students with completion of the doctoral program. Established
last year, the Thomas Edwin Devaney Dissertation Fellowships
provide a 50 percent stipend and tuition waiver for five credit
hours for working on a dissertation. Students must be enrolled
full time in the humanities or arts.
Goodland, Marianne. "All-But-Dissertation
Candidates Find Help at Camp Run by UCD's Foss." Silver
& Gold Record [University of Colorado at Denver], July
6, 2000, p. 4.
|